Politico · 2026-11-19 00:13:57

Russia, Vatican lead gender backlash at climate summit

Russia, Vatican lead gender backlash at climate summit
ANTALYA, Turkey — The Vatican is teaming up with Russia to block references to gender recognition in talks underway at the U.N. COP31 climate conference, drawing pushback from the European Union, four diplomats involved in the talks told POLITICO.

In the negotiating rooms where ministers and officials are now hammering out deals on issues ranging from finance to clean energy, Russia and the Vatican are rejecting most mentions of the word “gender,” they said.

The diplomats, who were granted anonymity because their governments have not authorized them to speak to the media, suspected the move is motivated by opposition to LGBTQ+ rights. The changes they described would narrow definitions in COP31 texts to exclude transgender people.

“It seems to be part of a broader anti-gender backlash,” said one of the diplomats, who negotiates gender issues on behalf of their country.

“They want to replace the word ‘gender’ with ‘women,’ and not even accept a reference to ‘all women’ but only ‘women’,” the same diplomat said.

Gender is part of climate discussions because researchers have found that the impacts of global warming disproportionately affect women and girls, including through increased gender-based violence and health risks during pregnancy. Marginalized groups and people affected by discrimination are generally more vulnerable to climate impacts, scientists say.

The EU has called on the blockers to drop their objections and stick to previously agreed language. The decade-old Paris Agreement, for example, calls for “gender-responsive” policies, a reference to policies which account for how climate change differently affects people of different genders.

“We are witnessing a growing and coordinated pushback by a few parties against fundamental principles underpinning effective and inclusive climate action, through active opposition to the best available science and information integrity, human rights and gender equality,” said a member of the EU delegation in Antalya.

The Vatican and Russia have the support of Argentina and Paraguay, two of the diplomats said. The Vatican’s press office and Russia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs did not respond to requests for comment. Neither did the Argentinian foreign ministry or Paraguay’s environment ministry.

Russia and the Vatican have found common cause on this issue despite being at odds on other global affairs, including Pope Leo XIV’s public expressions of sympathy for victims of Vladimir Putin’s aggression in Ukraine.

While the pope is considered to hold progressive views on some topics, he has not shown openness toward transgender people. While a bishop, he told the media: “The issue of promoting gender ideology is already a source of confusion because it seeks to create genders that do not exist.”

The dispute is affecting COP discussions on human rights and guaranteeing a so-called “fair transition” to ensure all citizens benefit from the shift away from fossil fuels. Consensus between all nations is required for any agreement during the negotiations.

A COP31 sign is seen in Antalya, Turkey on Nov. 7, 2026. | Chris McGrath/Getty Images

Another test will come in the language adopted for the final conference deal. A first draft of that decision makes several references to gender equality and “women and girls in all their diversity.”

“There’s a real push against gender-related language,” a second diplomat said. “It’s concerning.”

Two of the diplomats said they felt that similar-sounding comments from Russia and the Vatican in the negotiations suggested a degree of coordination between the two delegations.

“The Holy See views Russia as an ally on this,” said the first diplomat. “They’re using the same messaging. It feels coordinated.”

This isn’t the first time the two countries have campaigned to scrap gender-related language from climate texts. Similar efforts saw the Vatican team up with Saudi Arabia and Russia at the U.N. conference in 2024 to try and block language on gender rights from a COP decision.

The diplomats are concerned the dispute in Turkey may torpedo talks to agree on an Action for Climate Empowerment plan, a technical-sounding negotiation track that can determine whether governments help civil society participate in policymaking. The row over references to gender is blocking the plan’s adoption.

“Developing countries tell us that they need a tangible outcome here to give a mandate to their governments to allocate the needed resources,” the first diplomat said.

“The EU considers the Action for Climate Empowerment to be an essential part of driving inclusive climate action and putting people in its centre,” the EU delegation member said. “We regret that Parties were not yet able to clean the text on crucial issues.”

Countries last week approved a half-page decision text on gender that merely acknowledged agreements struck at the last COP summit to ensure climate policy is “gender responsive” — a far cry from draft texts that had suggested addressing gender disparities in policies, financial aid and the climate conferences themselves.

“We couldn’t even agree to ‘welcome’ progress,” the first diplomat sighed.

Source - www.politico.eu ↗