HELSINKI — The European Commission should withdraw and resubmit its proposal for a new EU-wide corporate law framework, startup lobby groups said, denouncing the current text as a “Frankenstein” proposal.
A position on the law adopted by EU capitals in October “weakened or removed some of the very provisions that would make EU Inc. a true European standard,” Startups for Europe and EU Inc. said in a joint press release.
Both groups pitched the withdrawal to European Commissioners Henna Virkkunen and Ekaterina Zaharieva, who oversee tech policy and startups, during a policy roundtable at Finnish technology conference Slush on Thursday morning.
Startups call on Commission to salvage or scrap EU Inc proposal

They also sent a joint letter to European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen earlier this week.
The European Commission published its proposal for a so-called 28th regime, also known as EU Inc., earlier this year, to harmonize how founders can incorporate a company and reward their personnel, so that startups can scale more easily across the bloc.
The scheme was seen as a challenge to the U.S. state of Delaware, which is known for its flexible incorporation laws.
Lobby groups now say that EU capitals have rolled back key provisions, such as the freedom to set up shop in any EU country and simplified insolvency rules. With their demand to withdraw and submit a new proposal, the groups hope that EU capitals will rethink their position.
“This is an opportunity for Member States to reconsider their positions and make sure EU Inc. delivers on its original promise,” said Simon Schaefer, president of Startups for Europe.
Jeannette zu Fürstenberg, managing director of General Catalyst, a fund that backed leading European companies such as Helsing and Legora, also criticized the EU Inc. proposal as it stands.
“If it comes out like that, it’s going to be Frankenstein that the whole world will laugh at,” she said in an interview at Slush.
She said the EU Inc. proposal should specifically address how stock options, often used to reward startup staff, are taxed.
“If you need to pay dry income on something that’s essentially illiquid, you’re bankrupting the people building it,” zu Fürstenberg explained.
A separate group of 38 tech executives, including Spotify founder Daniel Ek, Exor CEO John Elkann and Skype co-founder Niklas Zennström, took a softer line in a declaration published at Slush. They called EU Inc. “the most important first step” toward a true single market and did not ask for the proposal to be withdrawn.
They also urged Brussels to enforce the Digital Markets Act, the EU’s rulebook for the largest online platforms. Europe must “simplify regulation that limits growth and at the same time enforce competition law and the Digital Markets Act,” the declaration said.
Still to play for
The EU Inc. legislation has also hit a roadblock in the European Parliament, where lead lawmaker René Repasi’s report on it has yet to clear the committee stage. Repasi, a German Social Democrat, told POLITICO he could understand the frustration of the supporters of the original legislation.
“The political groups that in principle support EU Inc. should now quickly reach a common parliamentary position,” Repasi said, adding that this would enable the Parliament to negotiate in favor of key provisions for startups in the interinstitutional negotiations that are still to come on hammering out a legislative compromise.
Asked for comment, EU Justice Commissioner Michael McGrath said the objective from the outset had been “to establish a genuinely European corporate framework that is simple, attractive and enables innovative companies to start, grow and scale across the Single Market.”
While he did not directly address the criticism of the startups, McGrath said the Commission stood ready to work with the European Parliament and Council of the EU to “preserve the ambition” of the legislation.
“The forthcoming trilogues will be an important opportunity to address outstanding concerns and work towards an agreement that delivers real benefits for companies across the Single Market,” McGrath said in a statement to POLITICO.
This article has been updated.
Source - www.politico.eu ↗