Politico · 2026-11-20 01:32:08

The web is held together by volunteers. AI could tear it apart.

The web is held together by volunteers. AI could tear it apart.
BRUSSELS — Long before the fresh spate of hacks and website shutdowns, the inherent instability of the web was depicted in an internet-famous cartoon of a rickety tower propped up by a single small block.

Now a near-daily rhythm of outages suggests the supporting block may have come loose.

POLITICO revealed Thursday that internal services at EU institutions had gone offline after a major AI-fueled cyberattack. That came after service interruptions at U.S. national security offices and the federal aviation authority, global outages at Microsoft and a succession of internet-activated attacks on supermarket refrigerators in Europe.

Authorities blame the sudden wave of instability on the capacity of new AI tools to detect vulnerabilities in existing code and for bad actors to exploit them.

Interviews with more than a dozen cybersecurity leaders and those working on maintaining the internet show the scale of the challenge to keep the web up and running, in a world where the pace of finding vulnerabilities has rapidly and permanently accelerated.

Since the web’s early days, an unruly cast of idealist engineers and non-profit foundations have been essential for looking after decades-old critical code that’s been used to build our digital world. This small army of largely volunteer coders now say they can’t keep up with the power and pace of AI.

“We’re running on fumes,” said Robin Bender Ginn, executive director of the OpenJS Foundation, which looks after JavaScript, among the most widely used programming languages. “It keeps me up at night.”

Cybersecurity agencies around the world rang the alarm last month about major flaws detected in PHP, another critical coding language that underpins 70% of the web. This week, similar scares have spread over Java and NGINX, which also fuel large swathes of technology.

Helmut Reisinger, the European chief executive of cybersecurity giant Palo Alto Networks, said in an interview that the company is seeing “more or less” ten times as many incidents compared to about four months ago. He predicts the constant drumbeat of attacks and scares in the last month is going to become the “new norm.”

The PHP Foundation, which was only established in 2021 despite the coding language itself existing since the early 1990s, has two members of staff and 13 contractors. “Having very few individuals responsible for some key piece of infrastructure is just problematic,” said Nils Adermann, a PHP Foundation board member.

Out of office

Many tools like PHP have their origins in the 1990s, when foundational software and programming languages were developed in the messy, community-minded early days of the web. Those that worked well or were useful were gifted as a common good, picked up by other software developers and became building blocks for a vast number of digital technologies on which governments, critical infrastructure and citizens now rely.

Many open-source software libraries form the basis for widely used software like Android. Facebook was originally built using PHP, and household names like Spotify, Etsy and Wikipedia are just some top destinations that still use it as the basis for their services and websites.

The homepage of the PHP website is seen in Singapore on Oct. 22, 2026. | Yong Teck Lim/Getty Images

When cybersecurity agencies and companies issued an urgent warning in October that there were major flaws in PHP identified with the help of AI, and that they should either update their systems or shut them down, it was a public revelation that the architecture upon which our digital world relies is almost comically fragile.

Adermann explained that it is common for people who have worked on a PHP project for years in their spare time — developing a level of specific expertise that’s very hard to replicate — to duck out when they start families or can no longer find spare time.

That became especially apparent during the process of fixing the recent PHP flaws: One person involved in pushing out technical updates had a scheduled medical procedure and “was simply not available,” he said. “It was like, ‘okay, how do we figure it out, who can even do this now?’”

“That was one of these things where it became clear that we have a pretty limited budget and a lot of this is just barely working,” he said.

The discovery of the flaws did not, in the end, result in a doomsday scenario, in part because many organizations took themselves offline or fixed their systems, and also because the PHP flaws turned out to be harder than expected to exploit.

Free riders

Along with the PHP Foundation, numerous other non-profit foundations exist to act as guardians of open-source software, including the Linux Foundation, Python Software Foundation and the OpenJS Foundation.

They are typically funded through a mix of government grants and donations from technology companies. Funding can be used to pay full-time staff to carry out security audits, rather than relying on volunteers who, though committed, may suddenly become unavailable.

Tech firms have been among the biggest donors because they benefit from the open source software on which their own offerings are based, and continue to contribute to many projects.

Some of the world’s largest companies, including Anthropic, OpenAI, Google and Microsoft, have clubbed together to back a Linux Foundation project called Alpha Omega, which provided funding that ultimately led to the PHP flaws being fully identified and fixed. The project has been a “tremendous help,” said Adermann.

Another key donor often cited by open-source figures is the German government-backed Sovereign Tech Agency, which invested €205,000 in PHP in 2023 to 2024, with another €223,680 committed for 2025 to 2026, Powen Shiah, a spokesperson for the agency, said in emailed comments.

Germany is widely seen as a leader in open source, and the agency considers the funds it hands out to be investments in “chronically underfunded” critical infrastructure rather than donations.

“Improving a single foundational component can strengthen thousands of downstream applications and businesses, delivering benefits across entire industries,” Shiah said.

Juhan Lepassaar speaks at an event in Kyiv on Feb. 7, 2024. | STR/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Yet even between government and private funds, the sums remain small, particularly when dispersed among so many organizations. Tech firms can also be capricious, cutting funding when they lose interest in a particular project.

“More organizations need to understand how fragile this infrastructure can be and see investment in it as part of their own security,” Shiah said. “Some companies already invest substantially, but the scale of their financial contributions usually doesn’t reflect the value they derive.”

Only a “tiny fraction” of the companies that depend on PHP contribute financially, Adermann said. By his calculations, companies make hundreds of billions each year using PHP but contribute nothing.

Ginn said one Big Tech company dropped out of her OpenJS Foundation’s top membership tier just recently, leaving only Microsoft remaining. She noted that an issue in recent months is that more cash is being funneled toward AI-focused open-source foundations.

The AI deluge

The rise of AI models and their capabilities of finding software flaws is putting more pressure on open-source software engineers, who are inundated with reports of vulnerabilities — some of which are false or exaggerated.

Reports of flaws discovered by AI are “quite verbose,” Ginn said.

Juhan Lepassaar, the head of EU cyber agency ENISA, said in an interview that the agency has observed a similar pattern of false positives.

ENISA is making a list of the most critical open source components that should be made more secure, either by providing “skilled people, or AI models and tools,” Lepassaar said. The EU also has an open source strategy, in part with a view to weaning itself off U.S. tech.

Those plans were made before AI rattled cybersecurity defenders worldwide. Some, like the German Sovereign Tech Agency, hope that the incident will put the needs of open source software on the map and prompt an intervention.

But many of those steeped in the ecosystem, like Adermann, have their doubts.

“I’m a bit pessimistic,” he said. “I worry that people will just not care enough to actually do anything about it.”

Kilian Hocke contributed to this report.

Source - www.politico.eu ↗