Politico · 2026-11-22 22:21:57

Global left rallies in Paris to make ‘not so radical’ case for taxing billionaires

Global left rallies in Paris to make ‘not so radical’ case for taxing billionaires
PARIS — The left wants voters to know there is nothing radical about taxing billionaires.

“Radical would be cutting their heads off. But we are not proposing that,” former Chilean President Gabriel Boric told a summit against “international oligarchy” in Paris on Saturday. A minimum tax on the world’s largest fortunes, he said, is “arithmetic.”

Boric was among the left-wing politicians, union leaders and economists brought together by French economist Gabriel Zucman at the Théâtre de la Concorde, a city-owned venue within sight of the U.S. embassy and a short walk from the Elysée.

The gathering drew lawmakers from the U.S. Congress and opposition leaders from Italy, Germany, Britain and the Netherlands, united in the belief that taxing the super-rich could help the left regain the political initiative.

Their pitch was that Zucman’s proposed annual minimum tax of 2% on billionaires’ wealth is a modest measure that most voters already support — and a potent answer to the far right.

“It’s the status quo which is radical,” said Zucman, who cites polls that put support for his tax in France at 86%.

“Remigration will not make your life better, but redistribution will,” said Elly Schlein, leader of Italy’s Democratic Party.

The summit ran for almost 12 hours in a hall the size of a small community theater that was packed for much of the day. Proceedings spilled into corridors and side rooms, where politicians and union leaders from the U.S., Europe and Latin America met between panels.

The event also marked the launch of the Paris Manifesto, a declaration against “international oligarchy” that pairs a minimum tax on the ultra-rich with protections for journalists and a new ownership model for AI companies. More than 100 researchers have signed it, including Nobel Prize-winning economists Joseph Stiglitz, Esther Duflo, Paul Krugman and Daron Acemoglu.

Most of those making the case were out of power, with Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani appearing by video message. Mamdani’s chief of staff, Elle Bisgaard-Church, attended and met European politicians and labor leaders.

The European Commission was not represented, while France’s presidential hopefuls stayed away ahead of next spring’s election. Their parties were represented by figures including Socialist leader Olivier Faure and Éric Coquerel, a lawmaker from the left-wing France Unbowed party who chairs the National Assembly’s finance committee.

Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz, economists Gabriel Zucman and Jayati Ghosh, Californian trade unionist Dave Regan, economist Thomas Piketty and journalist Juliette Garside at the Paris summit against the oligarchy. | Daniel Perron/Hans Lucas/AFP via Getty Images

Musk, Bezos, Arnault

The billionaires were present in name throughout the day.

Jesse Klaver, parliamentary leader of Dutch progressive party Pro, opened his speech by saying he had spotted Bernard Arnault — head of French conglomerate LVMH and a frequent target of Zucman’s — on an evening walk in Paris’ tony 8th arrondissement on his way in.

“I [first] thought that you invited him too,” Klaver said. “That would have been a great idea actually, because he could see what energy is here in the room — and that he should be worried.”

Arnault, France’s richest man, has called Zucman a “far-left activist.” The economist said the fight over his tax in France last year showed him the reach of billionaire media owners, who he said control at least 85% of the country’s private press. An LVMH spokesperson declined to comment on Arnault.

Elon Musk drew the most fire. Zack Polanski, leader of the Green Party of England and Wales, said the Tesla chief had called him “a scumbag and a traitor,” and proposed a “Musk tax” on social media companies to fund local news.

Nobel laureate Stiglitz cited Jeff Bezos’ ownership of the Washington Post as an example of the super-rich buying influence over the media. He dismissed warnings that billionaires would stop working if they were taxed: “They want to be top dog, alpha male,” he said.

Americans in Paris

The U.S. contingent arrived weeks after Democrats won control of Congress in midterm elections and after California voters rejected a one-time 5% tax on the wealth of billionaires.

Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) told POLITICO he will introduce a billionaire tax bill with Bernie Sanders, the independent senator from Vermont, in the first week of the new Congress. “We need to have a fight in the Democratic primary about whether we’ll have a wealth tax,” he said, referring to the 2028 presidential race.

The internal Democratic Party argument on tax is largely settled, said Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.) in an interview. “I think we’ve won that debate,” she told POLITICO.

Dave Regan, the union leader behind the California measure, said it lost only narrowly after its opponents spent close to $500 million. He said Gov. Gavin Newsom “should be ashamed of himself” for campaigning against it, and described “a bipartisan consensus at the very top of both political parties to defend the ultra rich.” Regan plans to put a permanent tax to voters in 2028, and is planning referendums in Nevada and Michigan.

Newsom’s office has argued that a state-only wealth tax would drive money and jobs out of California.

Both lawmakers had a message for Brussels, where European Council President António Costa is weighing a tax on U.S. tech giants.

“I think you should be active with your tools,” Jayapal said of the EU’s rules for Big Tech. Khanna called for a transatlantic approach to tax and antitrust, and said “it should not be the United States bullying or dictating to Europe.”

Waiting for power

Europe’s left had a fresh win to show off: Dutch lawmakers last week narrowly passed a tax plan that raises wealth taxes to pay for cuts to payroll taxes after two centrist governing parties sided with Pro.

“For the first time, we are going to tax millionaires in the Netherlands,” Klaver said. “A divided left loses. A united left wins.”

Elsewhere, however, the idea is stuck, with the French Senate rejecting Zucman’s tax last year. EU tax laws, meanwhile, need the backing of all 27 governments.

Manon Aubry, co-chair of The Left group in the European Parliament, told POLITICO that a wealth tax should be part of talks on the EU’s next 7-year budget. “The left remains the only, or at least the main, political force that is pushing,” she said.

Dutch Greens MEP Ufuk Kâhya told POLITICO that Europe wants greater security and a stronger economy without settling the question who will pay for it all. Of the European Commission, he said: “They want to eat the cake. But no, you have to also bake it.”

In France, economist Thomas Piketty said a billionaire tax could pass by referendum, on one condition: “We need to win the presidential election. This is the only detail.” The French left has “lots of left-wing candidates. Maybe too many,” he added. France votes next spring.

Critics dispute that diagnosis. François Geerolf, an economist at Sciences Po’s OFCE economic think tank, has argued that Zucman overstates how lightly billionaires are taxed.

But for some in the room, a wealth tax doesn’t go far enough.

“We need to eliminate billionaires, not just tax them,” said author Naomi Klein, who called for a cap on wealth. University of Massachusetts Amherst economist Isabella Weber told POLITICO that “even if we had the most perfect wealth tax, I don’t think it would be enough” without measures to bring down the cost of living.

Regan had a suggestion for billionaires who threaten to leave if they are taxed.

“We should all put our money together and give them the means to get to Mars,” he said.

Source - www.politico.eu ↗